Union Pacific Is Overvalued (NYSE:UNP)

Source: Forbes

The pandemic has practically caused business activity to grind to a halt. That’s bound to impact shipments of goods via railroads like Union Pacific (UNP). For the first 25 weeks of 2020, total combined U.S. U.S. rail traffic fell more than 13% year-over-year. This implies headwinds ahead for railroads. In its most-recent quarter Union Pacific’s revenue of $5.2 billion was down 3% year-over-year. Total rail traffic fell 7% Y/Y, while average selling price (“ASP”) rose about 5%. Q1 revenue was negatively impacted by disruptions in China’s supply chain. The impact of COVID-19 could cause even more disruptions.

Union Pacific Q1 2020 revenue. Source: Shock ExchangeOf the company’s three main product categories, only the Industrial segment reported positive top line growth. The other two segments fell in the mid single-digit percentage range. Bulk includes grain, fertilizer, food and coal. Coal and renewables revenue fell 24% year-over-year, and has been hurt by competition from low natural gas prices. Combined revenue for grain products and fertilizer grew in the mid single-digit percentage range.

Industrial revenue grew 3% Y/Y as revenue from chemicals plastics and energy and specialized markets grew by double digits. Revenue from metals and minerals fell by double digits, which partially offset growth in other areas. The Premium segment declined, primarily due to a double-digit revenue decline from intermodal. Intermodal is facing competition from trucking, which could persist for the foreseeable future.

Union Pacific Q1 2020 carloads. Source: Shock ExchangeBulk carloads fell 7% Y/Y due to a 19% decline in coal and renewables, partially offset by mid-single-digit decline in other segments. Low natural gas prices and weak demand could stymie coal for most of 2020. Industrial volume rose 3% due to a double-digit rise in energy volume, slightly offset by a 3% decline in volume for metals and minerals. Volume for the premium segment fell 12% on a double-digit decline in intermodal.

UNP Q1 2020 ASP. Source: Shock ExchangeUnion Pacific’s ASP rose 5% Y/Y. The Premium segment led the way with a 6% increase in ASP. If the company’s pricing power dissipates then Union Pacific’s total revenue could fall hard even after the pandemic subsides.

Cost Containment Efforts

Rail traffic has been slowing for a while, and railroads have responded with deep cost cuts. During the quarter Union Pacific’s operating costs fell 10% to $3.1 billion. Costs fell more than the revenue decline, which led to an improvement in the operating ratio. The operating ratio was 59%, a marked improvement over the 64% reported in the year earlier period. I would consider an operating ratio below 60% as best in class. It puts Union Pacific in the same category as the Canadian railroads known for their efficiency.

Compensation and benefits expense was about $1.1 billion, down 12% Y/Y. The company has been reducing its workforce, and it showed during the quarter. Compensation and benefits were 34% of total operating expenses. Union Pacific gets the biggest bang for its buck by cutting headcount and overtime. Purchased services and fuel costs both fell in the double-digit percentage range. Falling fuel costs is a knock-on effect of a slowing economy, and it has inured to the benefit of railroads.

The fallout was that EBITDA of $2.1 billion rose 9% Y/Y. EBITDA margin was 51%, up 400 basis points versus that of the year-earlier period. Union Pacific may continue to cut costs, but it may not lead to margin improvement if its top line continues to slow. The pandemic is expected to hurt volume going forward:

As you can see, our volume in the second quarter has started off slowing with the volume down 22% so far driven by auto production shutdowns and retail closure as U.S. demand is constrained by the pandemic-related social distancing and quarantine. Many of the auto manufacturing plants are scheduled to be shutdown until at least early May. Already our auto shipments have been down around 80% in the second quarter so far. Likewise, the recent projections in Mexico indicate that some manufacturing sectors like auto will be shut down for similar time periods as well. However, the CARES Act that was recently signed offers some upside to open the economy for business and improve unemployment for America plus it also encouraging to see that much of Asia is restarting production along with China’s recent purchases of U.S. grains.

Volume and revenue will likely fall sharply over the next few quarters. I expect margins to also crater. After the pandemic subsides there’s no guarantee Union Pacific’s rail traffic will return to previous levels.

The Stock Is Overvalued

Financial markets fell immediately after the pandemic began to materialize. The Fed has provided liquidity to the bond market to ensure companies have access to credit and announced a $2.3 trillion relief package for small businesses and local governments. This stimulus helped the Dow Jones (DIA) bounce off its March lows. Certain stocks may trade more on animal spirits and monetary stimulus than on earnings fundamentals. UNP has an enterprise value of $139 billion and trades just under 13x last 12 months (“LTM”) EBITDA.

I doubt consumer spending will return to previous levels, which could hold back the economy for quite some time. Rail traffic and Union Pacific’s top line will likely face headwinds as well. Said another way, I do not believe UNP’s valuation reflects the uncertain outlook for the economy or rail traffic.


UNP’s valuation appears too robust. Sell the stock.

I also run the Shocking The Street investment service as part of the Seeking Alpha Marketplace. You will get access to exclusive ideas from Shocking The Street, and stay abreast of opportunities months before the market becomes aware of them. I am currently offering a two-week free trial period for subscribers to enjoy. Check out the service and find out first-hand why other subscribers appear to be two steps ahead of the market.

Pricing for Shocking The Street is $35 per month. Those who sign up for the yearly plan will enjoy a price of $280 per year – a 33% discount.

Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.